- Resource System
- Forest ecosystem and associated watershed
- Resource Units
- Forest products
- Location
- Tziscao, Chiapas, Mexico
This research was conducted in Lagunas de Montebello National Park (PNLM) in Chiapas, the sourthernmost state in Mexico. PNLM is a small (6,022 ha) protected area situated in south-central Chiapas, along the border with Guatemala in the ecological transition zone between the central highlands and the lowland tropical rainforests of this state. These forests experienced extensive and severe fires in 1998, due to drought conditions following the El Nino event of 1997. This study documented forest status and analyzed common property forest management institutions following severe fires that threatened forest conservation. This paper argues that forests managed by the common property regime are less intact than federal foersts, yet still moderately conserved, and many attributes necessary for common property management are functional, despite the recent fire crisis.
This case was part of a study to determine whether the institutional design principles of Ostrom were, in fact, related to "governance success" by Cox et al. In that analysis, this case was classified as a success.
Common Forestry System
Resource System
A small community forest [size not specified] inside the 6,022 ha of protected area of Lagunas de Montebello Natural Park (PNLM)
Resource unit: firewood for cooking & lumber for building furniture and houses
Resource Users
1,200 members of the Tziscao community
Public Infrastructure Providers
Male-only community-wide assembly
Public Infrastructure
- Four community leaders in charge of conflict arbitration and sanctioning, including a Security Council.
- Rules and norms regarding the extraction of resource units.
Relationship 1
NI to RU: RU extract firewood and lumber and information about the state of the resource
RU to NI: RU participate in fire prevention efforts
Relationship 2
All male members of the community participate as members in the assembly.
Relationship 3
The assembly makes decisions about the use of the resource and elects the four community leaders (PIPs)
Relationship 4
[Not specified in the source document]
Relationship 5
Rules and norms about the extraction of firewood and lumber guide the resource users' interaction with the resource system.
Relationship 6
Resource users self-monitor each other's extractive activities and report non-compliant members to the community leaders or to the assembly.
Exogenous Drivers 7 (Resource System)
Activities in the PNLM outside of the community forest are monitored by the park staff.
Exogenous Drivers 7 (Public Infrastructure)
The status of "Ejido" (common property regime) is not recognized by the National administraton. Therefore, the land inhabited by the community is considered Federal land and part of the PNLM.
Exogenous Drivers 8 (Resource Users)
The police can monitor Tziscao people's activity, but can only report violations to the park staff. The park staff monitors and sanctions Tziscao people's activity in the area of the PNLM outside the community's area. The Mexican army can monitor and sanction Tziscao people's activity in any area, but its presence is unpredictable and unfrequent
Exogenous Drivers 8 (Public Infrastructure Providers)
[Not specified in the source document]
Human Infrastructure, Private and Human-Made (Resource Users)
[No specific mentions in the source document
Human Infrastructure, Private and Human-Made (Public Infrastructure Providers)
[No specific mentions in the source document]
Brady U, Arizona State University.
Geffner Fuenmayor C, Arizona State University.
Common Property and Conservation: The Potential for Effective Communal Forest Management Within a National Park in Mexico. Human Ecology. 32(6):703-733.
. 2004.